Philippe Grisar in conversation with Kris Matthynssens (viola), Pieter Stas (cello) about discovering and recording a special cd: KLANG auf Schön Berg La Monte Young Klang a composition by Wolfgang von Schweinitz (b. 1953)
Coffee and marzipan
Pieter poured spicy aromatic coffee from a small caffettiera Napoletana neatly divided into three small cups. A block of marzipan cut into irregular pieces awaited eaters. Kris and I peeked with pleasure at the fragrant black fuel. The coffee grinned that it was good; the conversation could begin.
The gentlemen of the Goeyvaerts string trio were delighted. A few days earlier they had captivated the audience at the Irish College (Leuven) with Musik für drei Streicher by Wolfgang Rihm. A broken string did not break the spell.
Yet it was exciting to get the work into their fingers. The trio engaged a new violinist. For practical reasons, the long-standing collaboration with Kristien Roels was ended. The demands were high; in addition to reaching Kristien Roels' high playing level, the violinists had to be available on concert dates and a 'click' would be more than welcome.
Now Fedra Coppens is part of the world-renowned trio. It clicks!
What follows is a conversation about vision, hard work, music… and friendship.
Klang, the Irish connection
Especially since the production of the Stabat Mater, the trio's reputation has grown worldwide. No Pärt fan can pass by their pertinent interpretation in just intonation. Shortly after, they were a central guest at the conference 'Arvo Pärt: Sounding the Sacred in New York'. And the following year they created Second String Trio at the Guggenheim Museum. By Charles Wuorinen (°1938).
This year, Eamonn Quinn, director of the world-renowned Louth Contemporary Music Society, invited the Trio to create Klang by von Schweinitz and to record a cd. In times of Deezer and Spotify, this testifies to courage and vision. Later they would also be one of the central guests for the Stations of the Sun music festival (Dundalk, Ireland). The festival, which has been growing and thriving since 2006, brings "the most famous contemporary musicians, performers and composers to Ireland" (Independent.ie).
Philippe: Plainsound String Trio KLANG auf Schön Berg La Monte Young…… with the dots at the end included, is a very intriguing title. How did you come across this work?
Pieter: We got to know the piece through Eamonn Quinn. He is one of the most fascinating programmers at the moment, a phenomenon [awarded the Forberg-Schneider-Stiftung's Belmont Prize for contemporary music].
Kris: He takes risks, sometimes miscalculating. But that's how it is.
Pieter: Indeed, he programs both tonal (sometimes almost kitschy) and experimental music. The inspiring man introduced us to the work and asked us to perform at the festival. He was enthusiastic about our performance and asked us to record the cd.
Kris: We were happy to do so, but we set some conditions. That we want to work with Piotr Furmanczyk, sound technician and music producer, and that we may record it in the STEM (city museum Sint-Niklaas). It is a venue where our music comes fully into its own.
Philippe: 'Schön Berg La Monte Young' references both the inventor of dodecaphony and the inventor of minimal music. Don't they seem like two extremes on the spectrum?
Pieter: Trio for strings from 1958 by La Monte Young (°1935) is indeed the first minimalist work ever written and it is dodecaphonic! He wrote it in the language of his time with series indebted to Schoenberg's Treatise of Harmony. However, La Monte Young makes all the notes so long that any connection between those notes seems to disappear. Because of this you no longer experience it as atonal but as a sound work. You are absorbed by it like in a painting by Mark Rothko. Gradually you discover the entire texture of that single note. Von Schweinitz's trio's idea and of course its instrumentation is clearly based on this very first minimalist work.
Kris: He simply takes a chorale from Schoenberg's book and in turn stretches the work beyond recognition. He hides the basic material in such a way that the texture of the original material changes. He wrote the work in just intonation. Not the usual equal temperament that has been standard since Bach. In part because of the emphasis on sound and the intensity he demands during performance, he sharpens listening.
Just intonation is the old way to harmonically tune instruments taking into account ideal pitch intervals. Equal temperament divides all notes (including the sharps) neatly at equal distances. The latter tuning always sounds good; the first sounds either perfect or… difficult.
Pieter: Von Schweinitz, who studied under Ligeti among others, is part of plainsound.org. A collective that works around just intonation. It is important, they say, to be immersed in the music to be able to taste it because theory connects practice. [see also: www.marcsabat.com/pdfs/JI.pdf]
For us too, that was a special exercise. His system forces the musician to let notes sound in their richness. With that pure tuning, you know – or rather you feel how it should sound, but playing remains fragile. The same phenomenon occurred with the Stabat Mater by Arvo Pärt. The dissonances that sound along at the beginning can be resolved electronically. Then that sound is stable. But the human quality, the fragility of the moment is no longer felt. The listener now experiences the tension that is in it.
Kris: Yes, then it is merely beautiful. That Plain Sound resists that beauty. You have to listen slowly or you're not along. You have to feel. With the Stabat Mater we experienced that a chord sounded right but it needed time to settle. Nobody changed anything, but still the chord settled. That has to do with waves, residual frequencies.
That intensely human experience you can also have at home with this Klang production as a reviewer wrote. You don't have that with all works. For example, the string trio by Wolfgang Rihm doesn't easily set itself at home while live it is quite an event. This work, Klang, you can safely put on at home and listen to, experience. Yesterday an amateur musician told me about Klang: "if you sit quietly, you really hear it. Something happens that touches you."
Pieter: At one moment while listening to it I thought for a moment that I heard it inverted? That inverse time experience was strange, intangible.
Philippe: Unlike the Stabat Mater which takes you to an intense, rather sorrowful experience, Klang remains freer. But it creeps under your skin just the same. Von Schweinitz received the recording very enthusiastically, as you mentioned before. How do you record something like that?
Pieter: This kind of music is extremely suitable for strings but it is no gift. The physical given of the resonating strings and the instruments in a space determines much. So each performance is a unique event. We wanted to preserve the arc of tension and the physical given. That's why we chose to play the piece through each time in one go. Three or four times, we said to sound engineer Piotr Furmanczyk. But it easily takes more than an hour to get into the right atmosphere. Often you have to retune and also tune with each other.
Every 5 minutes there is a bar line where you could cut and paste. With Schoenberg or Pärt where the story plays a bigger role, you can more easily reconstruct an ideal recording. Now you as a player are also taken along in the sound of the moment. The next time you play it through, it can bring different experiences.
Kris: It can also fail. The piece imposes itself on us.
Philippe: The cover seems to impose itself somewhat as well…
Pieter: Previously we had to take the entire production in hand and think about everything. Now it was easier because Eamonn took care of the post-production, the cover, the text, etc.: a real luxury. We only had to concentrate on the performance.
Eamonn Quinn knows everyone, so also Storm Studios [stormstudiosdesign.com]. The firm designed the iconic cover of Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd, the prism. They have a kind of box with suggestions for other clients that didn't make it. Those remain pearls. A good cover is important. There were other suggestions but the photo of that man with two ears fits perfectly actually: listen!
Kris: Meanwhile there is also a radio edit that you may have already heard on Klara. This more than 5 minute long version as well as the complete version can also be found on Spotify, Deezer or in the better record store.
The trio already performed the piece at their own festival Passages, in the same hall where it was recorded. This year it will be a work by Reeves (February 16, 2020).
Finally
The empty cups and the few pieces of marzipan that remained only struck me when Kris mentioned he had to leave. With all that chattering - and joking in between, the clock unexpectedly announced noon. The three of them would rehearse that afternoon for the program Spiritual Lab. Pieter and I stayed with the remains of marzipan and continued talking about the work with and by Robin Verheijen 'Red, Blues and Other Songs' which will soon be created in the Amuz (November 24, with Robin Verheijen, Mark Copland and the Trio).
A few weeks later I finalize the interview and the cut in the cultural sector fell like an axe on a tree. Art connects. The avant-garde of today becomes 'canon' tomorrow and also influences popular culture. Flanders was once great at connecting and innovating. That's how we created the canon – or did you think Saint Nick was twisting his marzipan with Flemish almonds?
Quiz question: In what kind of political regimes does one find the same kind of statements?
- WHAT: Plainsound String Trio KLANG auf Schön Berg La Monte Young
- WHO: Wolfgang von Schweinitz, Goeyvaerts Trio
- CD PUBLISHER: Louth Contemporary Music | art.nr. LCMS19032020
- PORTRAIT PHOTO: © KMSKA, Jesse Willems
- WHERE: Festival Passages, Zwijgershoek 14 Sint-Niklaas
- WHEN: February 16, 2020

