In the cd booklet, Belgian musicologist Jan Christiaens discusses in detail the relationship between the organ works of César Franck (1822-1890) and the revolutionary innovations applied at that time by the highly influential organ builder Aristide Cavaillé-Coll (1811-1899), also the founder of the symphonic organ with its extremely rich sound. The perhaps best-known organ from his hand is located in the Parisian Saint-Sulpice, an instrument with no fewer than 100 registers and 5 manuals.
Franck – and he was certainly not the only composer – regarded the organs of Cavaillé-Coll as a symphony orchestra in itself, and he also composed accordingly. This is also what Christiaens notes in his commentary: that the collaboration between Franck and Cavaillé-Coll formed the basis for a new approach to organ music, primarily tailored to symphonic organ playing.
Cavaillé-Coll's aim was to enrich the organ sound as much as possible by adding extra registers on multiple manuals. However, there was a substantial drawback to this: at tutti, the wind supply might not be sufficient for a stable sound image, while the coupled manuals certainly did not facilitate the playing of fast passages.
This awareness was not only present among the organists, but also among the organ builder himself, who therefore worked on practical solutions in his workshop. He integrated the newly patented Barker machine, a system based on air pressure, which significantly facilitated playing. In addition, he made an important improvement to the swell box, which – thanks to its thicker walls and better-sealing shutters – allowed for a wide range of dynamic nuances – from subtle, restrained tones to powerful sound explosions.
From the middle of the 19th century, it was widely recognized that Cavaillé-Coll's organs could match the symphony orchestra in terms of sound and power. Franck shared this opinion, as evidenced by his statement: "My new organ is an orchestra!" upon his appointment in 1851 as organist of the Saint-Jean-Saint-François church in Paris, then an important step in his career.
We see in that period a perfect convergence between the innovations in organ development, their positive influence on playing technique and on the new organ literature. When Franck began work in 1858 as titular organist at the Sainte-Clotilde church, he had the opportunity on 19 December 1859 to premiere together with French composer Louis James Alfred Lefébure-Wély (1817–1869) one of Cavaillé-Coll's new masterpieces, which also marked the birth of his first major organ work: the Six Pièces.
The complete organ works of César Franck recorded on two cds by Belgian organist and music teacher Ignace Michiels (Brugge, 1963) should also be considered a jewel in terms of performance. Many organ lovers would have expected little else from an organist who, in addition to an impressive education – he studied at the Lemmensinstituut in Leuven, the conservatories in Brussel, Gent and Paris (where he won the Prix d'Excellence) – has built up a broad repertoire over the years and enjoys worldwide recognition.
Michiels lets the music speak. This may seem both a simple and obvious observation, but you will find organists who indulge in mannerisms and exaggerated virtuosity in Franck's works (and he is not alone in this). Those who have little regard for solidity and restraint, but precisely thereby let the music itself speak less. Michiels fortunately applies different, better standards, which in my view allows Franck's organ work to come into its own.
But then… Michiels did not use an organ by Cavaillé-Coll but that of Klais in the Sint-Salvators-kathedraal in Brugge, incidentally one of the most iconic buildings in the city, also the main church of the bishopric of Brugge. You will find here the specifications and an image of the organ.
Franck enthusiasts and organ lovers may well prefer to hear his organ works on a Cavaillé-Coll (recorded by, among others, Daniel Roth, Michel Bouvard (here reviewed by Siebe Riedstra), Bram Beekman and Piet van der Steen), but the Klais organ also unfolds great allure under the hands (and feet) of Michiels thanks to its symphonic proportions. One could also say: whoever is not generous in this respect misses much. And that amid so many recordings of Franck's organ works (though not all of these may still be available).
Michiels is a tremendous organist who brings Franck's music incomparably to life on an equally impressive organ. According to the recording information in the booklet, these organ works were recorded in one day: on 24 May 2024. If that is indeed the case, this represents an unprecedented feat. Just one very small point of criticism: the cover says Organ Works, but since this is Franck's complete organ oeuvre, this should have been mentioned. But aside from that: highly recommended, this formidable edition!