At the Opéra Royal de Wallonie we regularly have the opportunity to see lesser-performed works, such as Giordano's Mese Mariano last month. But the popular repertoire is of course not neglected either. So currently one of Verdi's top pieces is on the programme: Rigoletto. Indestructible thanks to Giuseppe Verdi's music alone and performed by talented voices, the production provides pure enjoyment.
Yet the direction gives rise to some reservations. The director chose a very gloomy staging that only really has a poignant impact in the last scene of the third act, in an almost surreal setting. The palace of the Duke of Mantova in the first act already seems to be in decay and the courtiers don't really come to life as the cynical counterparts to the hunchbacked fool, who takes the arbitrariness of power to task. Even the threatening figure of Monterone, who utters the curse over Rigoletto because he ridicules him as a cuckold, comes across merely as a puppet. We do like sobriety, but the cottage where Rigoletto lives with his daughter Gilda is presented very miserably, and the whole undertaking of Gilda's kidnapping also doesn't have the surprising impact. So every scene lacks a certain sharpness to really be memorable. A pity, but fortunately the singers make up for it somewhat with their strong vocal performance.
[caption id="attachment_28579" align="alignleft" width="556"]
© J. Berger[/caption]
Voices rescue the poor direction
The opera is primarily known for the famous aria of the Duke "La donna è mobile" but before that, tenor Giuseppe Cipali demonstrates with his opening aria, "Questa o quella", which shows that for him women exist solely for his pleasure, already makes it clear that he has a clear and powerful tenor voice, which throughout the opera very convincingly brings his character to life. In his aria "Ella mi fu rapita" he expresses credible rage because his love was stolen from him when he was courting her in her cottage. The abduction had in fact taken place by his own courtiers as mockery directed at Rigoletto. But in the cabaletta "Parmi veder le lagrime" a bit more cantabile nuance would have made his supposed sorrow more believable. The highlight is of course "La donna è mobile", which certainly on the repeat - while Rigoletto in the sack discovers his daughter's body - sounds heartrending.
Like the tenor, Rigoletto, baritone Sebastian Catana, has his great moments in his arias. Just as with the tenor, he is placed almost centre stage during those arias, so that they are almost impressive monologues that not only advance the action, but especially provide insight into the character's emotions. A turning point at which Rigoletto definitively takes on the role of father is the wrathful aria "Cortiggiani, vil razza dannata", mean bunch of courtiers, when he realizes they have abducted his daughter. His social role as a cynical fool is bitterly crossed by his grief as a father and from then on the individual dimension of the opera, Rigoletto as father, becomes paramount. Standing as a broken man centre stage is Sebastian Catana. Every confrontation between Rigoletto and Gilda in John Turturro's direction are intense moments that clearly suggest that the theme of father and daughter lay close to Verdi's heart. This is of course especially the case when Rigoletto finds his daughter again in the Duke's palace after he has raped her. In their duet Daniel Oren lets the strings and cello weep intensely with him. A moving moment. From here on, John Turturro gives the colour red a visual part as an aspect of hypocritical love, also found in the clothing of Maddalena, the sister of the hired assassin Sparafucile.
Lucie Kaňcová stood in as Gilda for the ailing Jodie Devos. She was a splendid replacement, who played the fragile yet determined girl with feeling. The aria that assesses Gilda, "Caro nome", she sang with a fresh voice, beautiful coloratura and simple empathy. She gradually abandoned the initial naivety for a convinced woman who chooses her beloved, even though it makes her the victim of a frivolous good-for-nothing. She therefore received a well-deserved overwhelming applause for her performance.
The choir performs vocally fairly well but their appearances remain, like the overall effect of the staging, quite pale and characterless. This is also somewhat the case with the orchestra, which does have some beautiful moments, although conductor Daniel Oren does his best to spur it on. Especially in the final act, it gets going well. Although the production certainly offers some beautiful moments, it will not make my top list of the Opéra Royal de Wallonie.
WHAT: Giuseppe Verdi Rigoletto
WHO: John Turturro, direction Daniel Oren, conductor Sebastian Catana, Rigoletto; Lucie Kaňcová, Gilda; Giuseppe Cipali, Duca di Mantova and further: Rubén Amoretti, Sarah Laulan, Patrick Bolleire, Patrick Delcour, Caroline de Mahieu
WHERE: Opéra Royal de Wallonie Liège
WHEN: Performance seen: Sunday 6-3-2022 More performances Liège until Sunday 13-3 / Charleroi: 18-3-2022