The subtitle of this book makes it immediately clear that the Nazis' relationship with classical music was at least problematic. Hitler, for example, was a great devotee of Beethoven, loved Wagner and Bruckner. Not so strange, they were true Aryans, and in Wagner's case also had a positive antisemitic track record.
But what to make of the gramophone records with music by the Jews Offenbach and Mendelssohn that were found in the Führer's bunker after the war? Recordings by lice in the Nazi fur violinist Bronislaw Huberman, Beethoven specialist piano lion Arthur Schnabel. How did music by these Jewish Untermenschen end up in Hitler's record cabinet? The answer is simple. If those Untermenschen could make good music, it didn't matter to him. But of course those records were locked away, because as Führer he had to remain credible.
In a colorful collection of nineteen short portraits of composers and musicians, former radioman and music journalist Fred Brouwers manages to sketch a striking picture of the arbitrariness with which artists during the Third Reich were confronted and the circumstances under which they were forced to live and sometimes to die. Those circumstances did not always bring out the best in people.
Some heroes therefore fall from their pedestal with a thud. Stravinsky's appalling antisemitism, the brutal opportunism of vain Herbert von Karajan who would become the founder of the postwar German music industry, the weathercocks Franz Lehar and Richard Strauss, the childishly naive Mengelberg, who fell from his pedestal in the very first days of the war and with whom things would never be right again, rabid Jew-hater Elly Ney who would escape her punishment, to name a few of the survivors. Not to mention the tyrannical hothead Arturo Toscanini, who despite all his many good deeds still comes across as an insufferable man.
However, not everyone was in a position to save his skin. A big name was not always enough to stay out of the Nazis' claws unless your name was Fürtwängler. That circumstance provides a number of harrowing stories with as low points the moving history of 'hit machine' Fritz Löhner-Beda who would not survive the hell of Auschwitz and whose murderer was acquitted in 1968 for lack of evidence. Or the gruesome fate of the 'little Caruso' Joseph Schmidt in supposedly hospitable Switzerland. He would not survive it.
Much of what Brouwers describes was of course already known, but through his gripping style and his apt characterization of famous and lesser-known musicians, he manages to captivate the reader from beginning to end. Moreover, he is excellently documented, remains always nuanced and avoids judging despite his deep involvement with the subject. The deeds speak for themselves. 'Being wrong' comes in many forms, as becomes clear.
This whets the appetite for more! Hopefully Brouwers still has enough material for a second volume! What about Elisabeth Schwartzkopf, Walter Gieseking and many others?
This book is a must for every historically interested classical music lover who should prepare himself for the fact that after reading it his record cabinet will never look the same as before.
- WHAT: Beethoven in the Bunker - Musicians under Nazism, honored, banished, gassed
- AUTHOR: Fred Brouwers
- PUBLISHER: EPO 2019
