Skip to content
Dit is een volledig nieuwe website, vond u een bug, stuur ons een email op bestuur@klassiek-centraal.be
Automatically translated · original
Opinion

ELISABETHWEDSTRIJD 2024 FOR VIOLIN. A RETROSPECTIVE.

W
· 5 min read
Share this article
ELISABETHWEDSTRIJD 2024 FOR VIOLIN. A RETROSPECTIVE.

Competition or festival?

The Elisabethwedstrijd is now a thing of the past. After the final evening and proclamation on 1 June, the laureates perform throughout the entire month of June across the country, with orchestra or in a recital with piano. On 12 June, the three first laureates performed one last time at the "closing concert" of this violin session, in the presence of Queen Mathilde.

The competition is always a major festival, this year a violin festival. Everyone knows that the judging does not take place as in a sporting competition. This makes it all the more exciting. No one knows who will ultimately prevail. Names of favorites circulate, evening after evening there is a ranking of listeners and viewers on Klara and VRT Canvas, but often the winner is a surprise because the jury does not deliberate. That benefits objectivity, but it means that pronounced personalities, who can evoke both admiration and aversion, often do not get the place they deserve.

In both the semi-final and the final, the audience in the hall, via radio or internet, can listen to very different performers often playing the same piece. The same violin concerto by Mozart and the same solo sonata by Eugène Ysaÿe in the semi-final or the same contemporary mandatory work or choice concerto in the final. In this we heard four times the first violin concerto by Shostakovich or also three times the Brahms concerto. This allows the audience to compare the finalists with each other and assess them.

Contemporary classical

If there is a winner in the Elisabethwedstrijd, it is contemporary classical music. This year the mandatory work for the final Variations litaniques was composed by French composer Thierry Escaich. During the week of isolation in the music chapel, it is rehearsed and performed by the twelve finalists evening after evening. The audience gets the chance to become familiar with a contemporary piece, which often sounds very unfamiliar to many ears at first. This is perhaps the most commendable aspect of the competition: giving a broad audience the opportunity to hear, learn to know and appreciate a contemporary work multiple times.

It was often emphasized by commentators during this edition how high the level was this year. On a technical and musical level and in terms of endurance, that is correct. Decades ago, you sometimes had finalists who performed weaker in their final than in the semi-final. Finalists who let it slip in terms of intonation or musical expression due to stress or fatigue. When Japanese violinist Yayoi Toda won the competition in 1993, violist and commentator Rudolf Werthen laconically said: "She won because she was the only one who didn't play any wrong notes". In this final, twelve violinists stood who each gave a fully valid performance. For some, it was noticeable this year how they somewhat overplayed themselves in terms of tone or tempo. Too fast, too loud, too much bravura.

The Far East and Belgium

In this edition, ten of the twelve finalists were of Asian descent. A trend that has been noticeable for decades, since Japanese Yuzuko Horigome became the first Asian to win the competition in 1980. The six violin editions (2005, 2009, 2012, 2015, 2019 and 2024) of the last twenty years were dominated by Koreans, Japanese, Chinese and Americans with Asian roots. How does that happen? Greater discipline, more supple hands and fingers? We often hear in our country the complaint that young musicians are no longer motivated from childhood to strive for excellence and that this would also be visible in the competition's record. But what do we see when we add up the countries of origin of the 72 finalists from these six violin editions? In addition to countries from the Far East, the US, Russia and Ukraine, there are only two Western European countries with four finalists: Germany and... Belgium. As a small country, Belgium is thus the country that is best represented, taking into account the size of the population. The explanation for that is simple. The competition is better known in our own country than abroad, and among the general public in our country the Elisabethwedstrijd is a household name.

Russia and Ukraine

Despite Asian dominance, the Ukrainian winner Dmytro Udovychenko and also the second laureate Joshua Brown from the US had no roots in the Far East. "Sublime struggle, sublime winner," De Standaard headlined. However, some commentaries have questioned the winner. He played very expressively and intensely, but not optimally. He chose the first violin concerto by Shostakovich, which expresses the oppression of Soviet society during the Stalin regime. That immediately refers to the current tragedy in his country which has been ravaged for the past eighteen months by Russian aggression. It will not have had a conscious influence on the judging. But you never know how a judgment is formed in the mind of a jury member. It was not Udovychenko, but second laureate Joshua Brown who received the audience prize from both Klara and Musiq3.

During the proclamation Saturday night, winner Udovychenko caused a slight stir when he did not shake hands with Russian jury member Vadim Repin, as he did with all other jurors. Instead, he made a bow to Repin. A sign of respect, but his refusal of Repin's outstretched hand gave the competition and its prize a political tinge. Many disapprove of it. What does Repin have to do with Putin? There was another Russian on the jury, Dmitry Sitkovetsky, who migrated to the US as a young man in the seventies. Dmitry did get a handshake from Dmytro. Vadim Repin is the legendary winner of the Elisabeth Competition 1989, active internationally as a soloist. He lives in Vienna, but is director of his Trans-Siberian Art Festival in his birthplace Novosibirsk. That is under the patronage of Russian authorities and thus has ties with Putin's regime. Better not to shake hands, thought Dmytro Udovychenko.

Share this article

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave a comment

Comments are reviewed before they appear.

EN