Skip to content
Dit is een volledig nieuwe website, vond u een bug, stuur ons een email op bestuur@klassiek-centraal.be
Automatically translated · original
Reviews

Chopin Voyage - Yulianna Avdeeva

A
· 4 min read
Share this article
Chopin Voyage - Yulianna Avdeeva

In 2010, it was the Russian pianist Yulianna Avdeeva who, even before her compatriot Danill Trifonov, won first prize at the quinquennial International Chopin Piano Competition in Warsaw. She was only the second woman, after prize winner Martha Argerich in 1965. Yet it was not Avdeeva who subsequently got to bask in excessive public attention and who could enjoy the great appeal of the major record labels, but Trifonov, who in Warsaw, on the other hand, had to settle for a third prize that was disappointing not only for him.

Three years after winning the competition, the album with Chopin's two piano concertos appeared, on which Avdeeva was assisted by the Orchestra of the Eighteenth Century under Frans Brüggen. It turned out to be an important release, created thanks to the National Frederyck Chopin Institute, also based in Warsaw, and part of a series of recordings that had grown to considerable proportions in the meantime, with pianos from Chopin's time at the center. What certainly played a role in Brüggen's choice for Avdeeva was that this pianist also liked to play on old instruments, such as an Érard from 1849 at the time.

On her new Chopin album, which was given the title Chopin Voyage by Pentatone, Avdeeva also plays on a remarkable instrument and in a sense also of historical significance: the Steinway grand piano CD-18, formerly owned by Vladimir Horowitz, his 'house instrument' that could be heard in many recitals and on many recordings. Horowitz died in New York City on November 5, 1989, at the age of 86.

The CD-18 is nowadays part of the Steinway collection housed in the Tippet Rise Art Center in Montana, where this recording was also made. What stands out above all is the grand piano sound, which seems to be the spitting image of what can be heard on many recordings with Horowitz: the sonorous yet dry and therefore transparent bass lines and the somewhat bright treble. The Steinway technicians have—undoubtedly with a master hand—succeeded in preserving that original grand piano sound well.

In my review of her debut album, also released by Pentatone (discussed here), my impression was that of a star pianist who, with ultimate technical mastery, gave a formidable display of interpretative artistry, as was also the case for her aforementioned performance of the two piano concertos.

The reason this so distinctly positive image does not, admittedly in part, hold true for her Chopin Voyage in my ears has everything to do with the restrained expressiveness that characterizes her playing this time, although her interpretative authority is just as unmistakable as in her previous recordings (there are now eight of them, including five that are largely devoted to Chopin's works, while Trifonov is already approaching twenty).

What emerges in these new interpretations, though I am happy to make an exception for the flaming Polonaise-Fantaisie and Third Piano Sonata, is above all the both expressive and tonal balance that she has clearly sought to achieve, and has therefore focused less on expansive expressive power. This is inspired by her rock-solid conviction (she talks about it in the cd booklet) that Chopin composed these pieces surrounded by nature, just as Avdeeva is, surrounded by the magnificent nature in and around the Beartooth Mountains. Avdeeva:

'Chopin wrote most of his major last compositions surrounded by nature. I am grateful for the opportunity to immerse myself in the serenity of nature too, as I bring these masterpieces to life at the one and only Tippet Rise Art Center, in Montana.'

It is a view for which I certainly have appreciation and respect, but a bit more expressive power and a bit more attention to expansion (tension arcs!) would, in my view, have made precisely that difference between good and great. But that she also lends the profile of the star pianist to this album is beyond any doubt. The grand piano sound comes magnificently through the speakers.

Details

Who
Yulianna Avdeeva (piano)
Share this article

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave a comment

Comments are reviewed before they appear.

EN