Skip to content
Dit is een volledig nieuwe website, vond u een bug, stuur ons een email op bestuur@klassiek-centraal.be
Automatically translated · original
Reviews

Debussy – Images

A
· 13 min read
Share this article
Debussy – Images

Virtually no composer developed their own style from the very beginning, and Claude Achille Debussy (1862-1918) was no exception in this regard, though some nuance is certainly warranted here.

Around his twentieth year, he stood as a composer and pianist in the midst of what was then popular and cultured entertainment in France, particularly in Paris: the composing and playing of melodious pieces, often miniatures, in an entertaining but rather predictable style, specially intended for home music-making by more advanced amateurs. There were certainly also pieces whose virtuosic character drew a sharp line between amateur and professional. Among the composers who engaged with the genre were Georges Bizet, Camille Saint-Saëns, Jules Massenet and Eduard Lalo.

One might therefore think that Debussy drenched his piano works in this style during that period, but this is only occasionally the case. Not only because they are not overtly virtuosic, but also because the zest for life so deeply rooted in music of that era (albeit not infrequently with a double bottom) as a stereotype is absent. Examples of this are also to be found on this album, with the Suite bergamasque, the Deux Arabesques still under the influence of Edvard Grieg (ca. 1890) and the Nocturne (1892) reminiscent of Chopin in the foreground. The Tarantelle styrene (1890, rev. 1903), by contrast, is virtuosic, has scherzo character and was created in the same period as the Suite bergamasque. Although stylistic elegance prevails in the majority of these pieces, they already contain elements as precursors to Debussy's later, mature style.

Pour le Piano (1894, rev. 1901) is one of the first piano works in which the mature style already announces itself convincingly. The piece is not free from the then equally popular exoticism (the Javanese gong sounds in the Prélude speak the language of the mysterious East), undoubtedly inspired by the World's Fair in Paris in 1889 and where, among many exotic instruments, the gamelan was also to be seen and heard. The entire piece breathes a rare, mixed atmosphere of old and new, with its distinctive, long-sustained harmonic effects (the carefully considered use of pedal plays an important role), the far from ordinary blending of legato and non-legato, the many dissonant chords that refuse to resolve into consonants, and indeed the diatonic-governed triumphant cadence.

Though the piece may stylistically allude to Baroque dance forms, it is above all its ambiguous character that expresses itself in the cheerful semblance of simplicity in the rhythmic constitution of the Sarabande and the metrical ambivalence in the concluding Toccata (in which the spirit of Domenico Scarlatti hovers).

The semblance of simplicity in the Sarabande? Yes, for it is deceptive. While both outer sections still fall within what may be called traditional writing (though the Prélude is no longer supported by classical proportions and in the Toccata a new harmonic 'language' is already discernible, albeit one in which the swollen conclusion is more of a bow to Romanticism), the Sarabande, by contrast, stands out through the new tonal relationships we find again in the Sarabande (Souvenir du Louvre) from the Images oubliées, as a reference to a painting in the Louvre - in the far from ambiguous key of C sharp minor from the same period (1894). It is a sound language that can do without full-fledged chords and optimally brings out the 'light-footed sadness' that hangs over the piece.

In Estampes (1903), it is again the characteristics of the gamelan that attract attention, but the Javanese mood is determined above all by the ingeniously developed pentatonicism, the series of five tones (not a scale) which here – unlike in Grieg's equally pentatonic Morgenstimmung - creates a distinctly Oriental atmosphere.

Though it may seem somewhat fashionable, particularly in light of the World's Fair, it is nonetheless a fact that Debussy succeeded as no other then in unfolding an entirely new world of sound, thereby keeping far from an Orientally-oriented musical 'travel guide'. In the CD booklet, the pianist explains it as follows:

'Javanese 'mood', inescapably orientalist to twenty-first century minds, is enhanced by the remarkably non-Western melodic marking 'délicatement et presque sans nuances'. Java had neither chords nor pagodas, but Debussy was fashioning a new world in sound, not a travel guide. Melodies and harmonies float, 'normal' rules suspended; Lisztian filigree stands still; stasis supersedes development. Fourths, fifths, seconds, and unisons, their merging of vertical and horizontal bringing Debussy closer to Schoenberg than either might imagine, create a world unmistakeably 'other', though necessarily anchored in Debussy's own.'

It is tempting to view Debussy's music at least in part in the light of Impressionism from the perspective of the then fashionable visual arts (Cézanne, Renoir, Degas and others), of which the two sets Images (which incidentally have nothing to do with the Images pour orchestre) would then serve as an explicit example. The composer did not elaborate on this. However, he wrote about the first set to his music publisher Durand: 'Without false pride, I have the feeling that these three pieces are fine works and will take their place in piano literature to the left of Schumann or to the right of Chopin.'

The first set was created between 1901 and 1905, the second in 1907. Both groups of three pieces each are similar in conception.

The opening section of the first triptych is intimately naturalistic in tone. Reflets dans l'eau, the musically masterfully developed suggestion of reflections in water, certainly recalls Liszt's equally enchanting Les jeux d'eau à la Villa d'Este. La Mer as a reflection of an infinite and rough sea is far removed here.
The second section is intended as a tribute to Rameau (in Debussy's words: 'dans le style d'une Sarabande mais sans
rigueur'). Without 'strictness' then, which in this case means that only the basic tempo, in the form of a stately, baroque dance, evokes earlier times, for the music seems more akin to the introductory measures of Wagner's Parsifal!
The third section, Mouvement (Movement) is that in the most literal sense: very moving indeed, though this applies only to the underlying rhythm. The piece already foreshadows the later Études but also readily connects with a sonata by Domenico Scarlatti (for whom Debussy must have harbored great admiration).

The opening section of the second triptych, Cloches à travers les feuilles, (Bells ringing through the leaves), is dominated by - it has become an eloquent recipe - the indeterminate, constructed in a polyphonic world from the whole-tone scale, gradually transitioning into the bright and sunny E major. En route, tonality is suggested rather than confirmed. Alfred Cortot remembered Debussy's painting as that of scarcely perceptible leaf rustling with the echo of gamelan sounds in the distance.
The second section, Et la lune descend sur le temple qui fus (And the moon shines on a former temple), was dedicated by Debussy to his friend, the sinologist Louis Laloy, who is said to have given him the title. Again we hear the sound of the gamelan, and just as clearly as in Pagodes. It is all musical imagination, of a landscape at rest, illuminated by soft moonlight and melodically so strongly constructed that this little piece could have managed even without harmonic support. It is, like the other sections not discussed here, a textbook example of what a Debussyian 'image' can achieve.

The exuberant, extroverted and virtuosic L'isle joyeuse (1904) is unthinkable without the French singer Emma Bardac, with whom the composer maintained an intense, extramarital love affair. What preceded it?

Like many wealthy Parisiennes around the fin-de-siècle, Madame Bardac regularly held a musical soirée in her salon, where many artists of all kinds made their presence known, including Gabriel Fauré. In 1877, his fiancée, a Parisian singer, abandoned him, which drove the already troubled composer almost to despair and subsequently plunged him into a loveless and soon completely embittered marriage; with the result that he gave himself over to numerous extramarital escapades. One of them concerned Emma Bardac, a beauty seventeen years his junior who responded to his advances. The Dolly Suite was almost a direct consequence of this, for Fauré composed this collection for four-hand piano specifically for Emma's daughter Régina Hélène, or Dolly, in the period 1893-1896. Fauré carefully provided each section with a title that somehow related to events or interesting facts about the Bardac family. Emma herself was also - how could it be otherwise - a source of inspiration, as evidenced by the song cycle La bonne chanson, completed by Fauré in 1894. That she was his muse for a considerable time is thus quite obvious, even if the relationship did not last.

[caption id="attachment_41291" align="alignleft" width="640"] Gabriel Fauré with the daughter of his hostess and host (Lombard) in Trevano, on Lake Lugano in 1913[/caption]

In October 1903, Fauré made way for a new 'lover', Debussy, then 41 years old and only a few weeks younger than Emma. Like Fauré, Debussy had also remained 'close to home' for quite some time by giving piano lessons to Raoul, Emma's son. And like his predecessor, Debussy too fell for the extremely charming, attractive, worldly and not unmusical Emma. Whether Lilly knew of this love triangle at an early stage is plausible, but certainly not at the beginning, when she still accompanied her husband to the soirées. She may have caught wind of it, however, for soon after, Debussy began visiting alone. Emma's world was not Lilly's world anyway, whom she found far too cosmopolitan, and moreover she had little appreciation for Emma's refined charms. It must have suited Debussy perfectly, for this cleared the way for what would culminate in a passionate love affair.

[caption id="attachment_41292" align="alignleft" width="640"] Debussy and Emma Bardac[/caption]

On Lilly, Debussy had meanwhile grown weary. In July 1904 he even sent her to her parents, only to sneak away on vacation with Emma shortly after. The destination the couple had chosen for this undoubtedly intense rendez-vous was the island of Jersey, where Debussy brought the love-filled L'isle joyeuse (The Joyful Island) onto manuscript paper. Only to substantially revise the work immediately upon returning to Paris. A different, more familiar environment that yielded different, equally more familiar insights, it would seem.

Lilly, on the other hand, saw only a dark future. After Debussy had made it clear to her that their marriage was at an end, she took a pistol, went to the Place de la Concorde and attempted suicide. After Debussy learned from her doctor that Lilly had survived, he moved in with Emma anyway. Parisian high society was abuzz with stories and rumors, a scandal seemed unavoidable. Especially Debussy's heartless conduct was held against him, compounded by the fact that he refused to pay Lilly's medical bills. And because he stood firm, musicians and other artists organized a collection for the impoverished wife abandoned by her husband. For Debussy, things did not go smoothly either, and it must have been particularly painful for him that so many friends and acquaintances wanted nothing more to do with him. The newlywed couple saw the many squalls gathering and departed for England to await there the storm raging over their heads until it had at least somewhat subsided.

The blissful L'isle joyeuse forms part of the well-known Trois pièces de 1904 (the title does not come from the composer), which also includes Masques and D'un cahier d'esquisses. Bringing them together under that common title was not such a strange idea, for there are certainly correspondences to be found between these three pieces, apart from the year of their creation. All three are not set contrapuntally and lack the characteristic of the étude. Which is not to say that they are simple pieces: the amateur will find them quite challenging and the professional can likewise scratch their head. Both musician and listener find themselves confronted with the indeterminate tonality that emerges here and there in an atmosphere of evocative and chiseled suggestion. The titles perfectly convey the musical content: Masques is a masquerade clothed in colorful dance richness, D'un cahier d'esquisses is intended as music from some sketchbook whose right direction has not yet been found, and therefore is quickly brought to a close (the dreamy piece takes less than five minutes)

The last piece of this triptych, L'isle joyeuse, is anything but dreamy, but rather bright, sunny and euphoric. According to connoisseurs, it is also based in part on a painting by Jean Antoine Watteau (1684-1721): L'embarquement pour Cythère, depicting a group of notables dressed in festive attire embarking with the Greek island Kythira as their destination, the birthplace of Aphrodite, who according to mythology was born in the foam of the waves surrounding the island, after the genitals of Uranus had been severed by his son Saturn and fallen upon her. Aphrodite, the goddess of love but also of beauty, sexuality and fertility. She was (her epithet was not without reason Kythereia) worshipped in ancient Greece as the goddess Urania. On the island the ancient Greeks built a temple in her honor.

Debussy employed an exceptionally fine pen for many of his creations, his musical imagination rooted in movements, events, circumstances, natural elements, landscapes. The dynamics are thereby deliberately often limited, while also evoking that magical suggestion of silence and stillness, often inspired by the purity of creative perception. Music that by virtue of its illustrative character is of an almost hypnotic beauty, and thereby pure and inviolate. The expressive gradations seem virtually endless.

That brings me to the playing of Italian-Dutch pianist Saskia Giorgini, which reminds me strongly of that of her French colleague Pierre-Laurent Aimard (or much further back the Dutch pianist Hans Henkemans), through its adventurous character, the impression too as if these were brand new compositions. But also through that so special combination of precision and adventure. These are interpretations that from beginning to end evoke the so greatly desired magic that ensures a unique listening experience. Giorgini, and fortunately as time progresses she is not the only one (the list of brilliant performers is only growing), rightly chose optimal clarity in the voicing, the articulation is phenomenal and the enchanting element in both the melodic and harmonic progression does not stem from the imposed mistiness, the vagueness, that is so often equated with French impressionism. There is at the same time much charm in her playing, but like Aimard it remains far removed from the nebulous or showy. Stylistically there is a considerable gap between their playing and that of, for example, Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli, for many still the touchstone with regard to a more personal (not necessarily better, but different) approach to this so specific idiom. Giorgini proves herself in these pieces 'modern' and thus completely free from historically formed ballast. The sonorous, but also clear recording helps considerably in this regard. The Bösendorfer perfectly intonated and tuned by Siebren van Hoog is recorded as magnificently as the exemplary piano playing of Saskia Giorgini.

Details

Who
Saskia Giorgini
Share this article

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave a comment

Comments are reviewed before they appear.

EN