Beethoven's Third and Seventh Symphonies both place large dramatic arcs and rhythmic tension at their centre, yet both works also demand attention to detail. In the Eroica, heroism and personal expression alternate, while in the Seventh the rhythm almost acquires an independent significance. Victor Julien-Laferrière and Orchestre Consuelo opt for a transparent approach, in which the individual voices remain clearly audible. This yields two lively interpretations, although one is slightly more convincing than the other.
The Eroica: youthful freshness and momentum
The first movement is played briskly, at an ideal tempo and with a masterful build-up. The woodwinds come through particularly beautifully, and the hushed moments are also given ample space. The slender sound suits this unconstrained approach well. Even in the acoustic of the magnificent abbey church, the balance is excellently maintained.
The second movement, the Marcia funebre, receives a lyrical, elegant reading. The tempo is rather high for a funeral march, but the music remains a delight to listen to, partly thanks to the attention given to the woodwinds. Nevertheless, I missed some depth in the character of mourning here, and a richer string sound. After a subtle hush, a climax follows that in my view is dispatched somewhat too quickly.
The scherzo is lively and playful. Noteworthy is the slowing just before the entry of the horns, which makes the rhythm suddenly calmer. This intervention gives the music a surprising accent. In the finale, the strings deliver the almost pleading theme with feeling. The build-up of tension towards the end is convincing, as is the alternation between soft and forceful passages. The horns sometimes come through less clearly here, but that does not detract from the fact that the movement has much to offer.
The Seventh: drive without bravado
The first movement impresses with a clear sound, a strong rhythmic impulse and room for contrasts. Julien-Laferrière keeps the musical line firmly in hand. A deliberate slowing, roughly five minutes after the beginning, creates a moment of relaxation. Towards the end, the deep bass lines of the strings come through particularly clearly.
The Allegretto sounds flowing and restrained, with a sense of nuance in the quieter passages. The performance is refined, although I occasionally miss some sharpness. As a result, the music acquires a lyrical rather than a truly restless character. This fits within this interpretation, but for me the undercurrent of tension could have carried through more strongly.
The scherzo is particularly enjoyable. The accents are well chosen and the alternation with moments of hush works excellently. The woodwinds and horns also contribute to the character of this movement, without placing themselves prominently in the foreground.
In the finale, the well-balanced choice of tempo stands out. The music gradually gains strength without turning into a contest of speed. The orchestral playing remains refined, with once again a striking role for the winds. The accumulated tension culminates in a finale that convinces through its control and natural momentum.
Beethoven on a chamber-music scale
Victor Julien-Laferrière made his name as a cellist and has also built up his own ensemble, Orchestre Consuelo. The musicians approach the symphonic repertoire with attention to the individual parts and their mutual relationships. The live recordings date from the Festival de La Chaise-Dieu in August 2025. The instrumental groups remain clearly distinguishable from one another, which benefits the transparent approach in these live recordings.
Especially in the Seventh, this approach yields much. The tempi are well judged, the rhythmic impulses remain lively, and each movement acquires its own character. In the slow movements of both symphonies, the lyrical approach stands out, but I sometimes missed the undercurrent of tension and depth that could have made the music even stronger for me.
These recordings show two sides of Beethoven's symphonic music. The Seventh convinces through its clear structure and natural momentum. The Eroica likewise has much to offer, although listeners who seek more weight and dramatic depth in the Marcia funebre will perhaps prefer a different reading.